Skip to content
◆ Smart Scholars🛡 Scholar Shield🏛 Research Integrity Desk🧩 Portfolio Console📰 Journals🔧 DOI MembersTools🔎 Journal AuditGI GetIndexedDr DOI Doctor
Indexing guidance

Web of Science indexing: ESCI, SCIE and the 28 criteria

How Clarivate evaluates a journal for the Web of Science Core Collection: two triage stages, 24 quality criteria for ESCI, four impact criteria more for SCIE, SSCI and AHCI, and what happens after the decision — from Clarivate's own page.

The four stages

Initial triage

  • A registered ISSN, shown the same way everywhere
  • A title that matches the ISSN, the scope and the content
  • A named publisher with a verifiable address
  • The journal's web address, with full access to current content for the evaluators
  • A clear commitment to peer review, with primary research reviewed externally
  • Contact details for the editorial and production staff

Editorial triage

  • Mainly original scholarly content
  • English titles and English abstracts
  • References, names and affiliations in Roman script
  • Clear English for a global readership
  • A stated publication frequency that is kept, with enough articles a year
  • A working website, linked with the publisher's site
  • Ethics requirements stated, with any guidelines credited
  • Editors and guest editors named, with affiliations and countries
  • Authors named, with affiliations and countries

Quality evaluation — 24 criteria in all

  • Title, scope, board, authors and content that fit together
  • A board whose size and make-up fit the output
  • Published content that follows the journal's own policies; accurate website
  • Evidence of adequate peer review
  • A well-defined scope and purpose
  • Funding acknowledged where the field expects it
  • Editorial policies in line with recognised practice, such as COPE's
  • Articles that follow the field's practice and cite its literature

Impact evaluation — 4 criteria

  • How often and by whom the journal is cited, against its field
  • Citation activity that holds steady over time
  • Authors and editors with visible publication records in the field
  • Content of interest and value to readers

A journal that passes the quality evaluation enters ESCI; one that also passes the impact evaluation enters SCIE, SSCI or AHCI, by subject.

Submitting the journal

The publisher submits through the Web of Science Publisher Portal, for a journal not yet indexed. The evaluators need full access to the journal's current content.

After the decision

No waiting period after initial triage, nor after a first editorial-triage failure; one year after a second in a row; at least two years after failing the quality evaluation. Covered journals keep being watched: flagship journals whose impact falls move to ESCI, and journals that no longer meet the quality criteria are removed.

Questions editors ask

What is the difference between ESCI and SCIE?

A journal that meets Web of Science's 24 quality criteria enters the Emerging Sources Citation Index (ESCI). A journal that also meets the four impact criteria — measured mainly by citations — enters one of the flagship indexes: the Science Citation Index Expanded (SCIE), the Social Sciences Citation Index (SSCI) or the Arts & Humanities Citation Index (AHCI), by subject.

How do I submit a journal to Web of Science?

Through the Web of Science Publisher Portal. Only the publisher can submit, and only for a journal that is not already indexed.

How many criteria does Web of Science use?

28: 24 quality criteria and 4 impact criteria. The quality criteria come first, after two triage stages that check the basics — ISSN, publisher, peer review, English titles and abstracts, a working website and named editors and authors.

What happens if Web of Science rejects a journal?

It depends on the stage. After initial triage there is no waiting period. After a first editorial-triage failure there is none either, but a second in a row means one year. A journal that fails the quality evaluation waits at least two years before it can be submitted again.

How does an ESCI journal move up to SCIE?

It cannot be requested. Clarivate monitors ESCI journals and re-evaluates them for the flagship indexes when their citation activity suggests they may meet the impact criteria; quality is checked first.

Can a journal be removed from Web of Science?

Yes. A flagship journal whose impact falls moves to ESCI, and a journal that no longer meets the quality criteria is removed under Clarivate's Removal from Coverage policy.

How long does the Web of Science evaluation take, and is there a fee?

Clarivate's page states neither an evaluation time nor a fee.

Can anyone guarantee Web of Science indexing?

No. Clarivate's editors decide. What can be done is to meet every triage and quality criterion in the journal's own hands before it is submitted.

How we help before a journal is submitted

We check the journal against every triage and quality criterion the public record can show, then put right what is in its hands: a consistent ISSN and title, the publisher's address, peer-review and ethics pages, English titles and abstracts, named editors and authors with affiliations, a working website and complete metadata. We never promise a listing — Clarivate decides.

Source of every fact on this page: Clarivate — Web of Science journal evaluation process and selection criteria (read 20 November 2026).

Indexing consultancy → Book a free callScopus: the CSAB criteriaPubMed: MEDLINE and PMCDOAJ indexing

Share this page

Share this page

Ask AI about this page

Everything Smart Scholars runs

Nine sites, one account. A journal starts at the audit; an author starts at Scholar Shield.

What we do: DOIs registered from what a journal already has · Crossref records completed — references, abstracts, licences, ORCID iDs, affiliations and ROR IDs, funding · DOIs that resolve · articles preserved · journals rated on the public record · see everything we do →

Book a free call

For journals & publishers

Start with the audit — ₹4,999 per journal, and the gate to everything else.

DOI care

Every service on one journal profile — each previews first and acts only on your approval.

For authors & researchers

Free to use. Nothing you check is shared with the journal.

For institutions, sponsors & DOI operators

Smart Scholars

Mon–Sat, 10:00–19:00 IST. The Ask AI button on every page answers about our services at any hour.

News

Policies

What we can register a DOI for

20 kinds of record, one account, one place. Every one gets a DOI that resolves, metadata that indexes read, and a record that stays correct afterwards.

Journals

  • Journal articles
  • Journal titles
  • Pending publications
  • Peer reviews
  • Preprints & posted content

Books & conferences

  • Books
  • Book chapters
  • Book series
  • Book sets
  • Conference proceedings
  • Proceedings series
  • Conference papers

Other research output

  • Theses & dissertations
  • Reports & working papers
  • Report series
  • Standards
  • Databases
  • Datasets
  • Figures, tables & supplements

Funding

  • Grants & funding awards

Elsewhere

The same company, in the places our publishers already read.
Add Smart Scholars as a preferred source on GoogleSee more of our newsroom in Google’s Top Stories.
Smart Scholars · Every service on one pageNewsroom posts CC BY 4.0 · DOI metadata CC0 · everything else ©Data from OpenAlex (openalex.org), CC0 · Crossref · ISSN Portal · DOAJContactCookie settings
WhatsApp